top of page

When Being Good at Your Job Becomes a Trap

6 days ago
7 min read

Stylised illustration of a businesswoman in a blue suit walking forward while carrying an enormous stack of files and folders. Despite the excessive workload, her expression remains calm and composed, against a vibrant turquoise background. Episode 38. What If Being a Good Leader Is Costing You Too Much? Proactive Empowered Careers with Patricia Ezechie
When carrying too much becomes normal, even an unreasonable workload can begin to feel ordinary.

There's something deeply satisfying about being good at what you do. Knowing that you can handle difficult situations. Being trusted with important work. Having people recognise your contribution and turn to you when something really matters.


And of course, there's the pleasure of being needed too, isn't there?


In knowing that your experience, your judgement and your willingness to go the extra mile make a difference. And for many of us, these are the very things that make work rewarding. Beacuse we want to contribute. We want to do well. We want to feel that what we bring matters.


But I've been thinking about what happens when the qualities that make us successful begin to work against us.


When the person everyone relies on becomes the person everyone assumes will always be available.

When the exceptional contribution gradually becomes the everyday expectation.

And when being extraordinarily good at what you do starts to cost you far more than anyone else can see.


How does something that begins as a strength gradually become a trap?



The pleasure of being capable


I've always been conscientious.

When I started secondary school, I remember a teacher expressing concern about the number of schoolbooks I carried home every night. I was determined to do well, and doing well meant putting in the work.


That determination followed me into my career.


I remember the excitement of stepping into my first substantial management role. I had been given an important responsibility, I was working with bright, ambitious people, and I wanted to prove that I was worthy of the opportunity.


So I worked extraordinarily hard.


And I enjoyed a lot of it.


The intellectual challenge, the responsibility, the opportunity to learn, the satisfaction of delivering something difficult.


I was ambitious, and I wanted to succeed. And I think that's an important part of understanding how these situations develop.


We don't necessarily begin by being overburdened or taken advantage of. We can begin by feeling excited, challenged and genuinely pleased to be trusted with something important. We give more because we want to, because we're capable of doing so and because doing well matters to us.


But our willingness to give doesn't exist in isolation. It can become part of the expectations other people develop about us. And that's where the relationship can begin to change.



When exceptional becomes expected


One of the curious things about being highly capable is that you can become remarkably good at making difficult things look easy.


You solve the problem, meet the deadlines, find a way around obstacles and step in when something needs doing. And because you do it well, people begin to trust that you always will.


At first, that trust feels like recognition. But each time you take on something extra and deliver successfully, you're also demonstrating what you're prepared and able to do.

And other people learn from that. The additional responsibility you once volunteered to carry becomes part of your normal workload. The extra hours become an unspoken expectation. Your willingness to help becomes something other people plan around. And what began as a choice gradually becomes an obligation, although nobody has explicitly said so, and the more successfully you manage it all, the less visible the effort it takes becomes.


Your competence has begun to conceal the fact that what has become

expected of you is unsustainable.


People see the results. They don't necessarily see what those results demand of you. And if you've always taken pride in being capable, you may be the last person to question what's happening because the expectations aren't only coming from other people anymore.


They are coming from you too.



When being capable becomes part of who you are


This is where I think the trap becomes really interesting.


When you've spent years being recognised for your competence, dependability and willingness to go further than expected, those qualities can become central to how you understand yourself. You're the person who gets things done, the one who can be relied upon, the one who doesn't let people down, and there's real satisfaction in that identity.


But it can also become difficult to behave in ways that seem to contradict it.


What happens when you don't have the answer?

When you can't take on another responsibility?

When you want to go home rather than stay and finish something?


Saying no may begin to feel less like a reasonable decision about your capacity and more like a failure to be the person you've always been. And this is where the expectations of the environment and the expectations we place on ourselves can begin reinforcing each another.


The organisation expects you to deliver because you always have. You expect yourself to deliver because that's who you believe you are.


So you keep going.


Not because anyone is explicitly demanding it, but because you've both become accustomed to that version of you, and somewhere along the way, the freedom to choose how much you give has narrowed or disappeared entirely.



The expectation of reciprocity


There's another reason these patterns can be difficult to recognise.


We generally don't give extraordinary amounts of ourselves to work without believing that something worthwhile will come from it.


Sometimes the reward is immediate: the satisfaction of doing something well, solving a difficult problem or helping someone succeed. But we may also expect something more specific.


Recognition. Opportunity. Progression. Loyalty. Support when we need it.


And these expectations aren't unreasonable. Work is a relationship, and relationships involve expectations about what each person contributes and receives.


But the difficulty comes when those expectations aren't shared. You may think that your extraordinary commitment is building a relationship of mutual loyalty and support. The person benefiting from that commitment may believe they're already rewarding you through the opportunities and experience they're providing. And because you're still delivering, neither of you may have much reason to question the arrangement.


Until something happens that reveals the difference.


Maybe the recognition you expected doesn't come, or the support you assumed would be there isn't. Or you discover that your willingness to give more has become something other people simply take for granted, and suddenly you begin to see the relationship differently.


The qualities that once brought you satisfaction are still there.

You're still capable, conscientious and committed.


But the relationship surrounding those qualities has changed.


Being needed is not necessarily the same as being valued

in the way you believed you were.


And recognising that can be painful, particularly when you've invested so much of yourself in the relationship.



How we learn to keep giving more


Of course, none of this happens in a vacuum.


Our ideas about what it means to be successful are shaped by the environments we work in and the people we see succeeding around us. We notice who gets promoted, who receives recognition and what kinds of behaviour organisations celebrate. So if the people we admire demonstrate their commitment through extraordinary hours, constant availability and a willingness to put work before almost everything else, we may begin to associate those behaviours with success. And if we're already conscientious and ambitious, that message can be particularly powerful.


We don't just learn how to do the work. We learn what we believe we must be prepared to give in order to succeed at it, and over time, those lessons become so familiar that we stop recognising them as assumptions. We treat them as the way things are. And that raises a question about congruence: whether the version of success we're pursuing still reflects who we are and what matters to us


And this reinforces the trap.


The environment rewards our willingness to give more.

We take that reward as confirmation that we're succeeding.

And the more successful we become, the more difficult it can feel to question the very behaviours that helped us get there.


Until the cost becomes impossible to ignore.



When success starts costing too much


I don't believe the answer is to stop being conscientious, ambitious or deeply committed to doing good work. Those are qualities worth valuing. But I do think we need to pay attention to what happens when they become distorted.


When being dependable means never being unavailable.


When being committed means continually sacrificing your own time.


When being capable means never admitting that something is too much.


And when the satisfaction of being good at what you do has gradually been replaced by the obligation to keep proving it.


Because there's a difference between choosing to give more at particular moments in our careers and feeling that we have no choice but to keep giving more indefinitely.


The first can be enormously rewarding. The second can become a way of living and working that leaves very little room for anything else.


And maybe that's the real trap.


Not that we've become too good at what we do, but that we've allowed our competence to become tied to a set of expectations that no longer serve us.


Expectations from other people, yes, but also expectations we've come to hold about ourselves.


So maybe the question isn't whether we should continue striving to be good at what we do.


It's whether we can remain good at what we do without having to sacrifice so much for it. Sometimes recognising that something has become unsustainable is easier than understanding what actually needs to change.


What have you come to believe you must give of yourself to be successful?


And is that still a definition of success you want to live by?



Listen to the podcast


In Episode 38 of Proactive Empowered Careers®, What If Being a Good Leader Is Costing Too Much?, I explore a related question: what happens when the qualities that make someone an effective and valued leader begin to make their leadership unsustainable, how Identity, Environment and Energy interact, and why the answer isn't always as simple as setting better boundaries.


🎧 You can listen to the episode below ⬇️






Continue exploring


If this reflection has resonated with you, and it has prompted you to think differently about the demands of leadership, the expectations we place on ourselves and what it means to lead sustainably, you might find these related conversations useful.


  • When Your Career Feels Out Of Your Control (Episode 29)

Explore how we recognise and exercise choice when familiar patterns of behaviour have become so automatic that we no longer stop to question them.


Consider whether the success we're pursuing, and the expectations we're working so hard to meet, still fit who we are and the life we want to live.


When you know something about your working life no longer feels right, understanding what needs to change is an important place to begin.



Explore Proactive Empowered Careers®

Discover more conversations about identity, agency, career decisions and creating a working life that reflects who you are and the life you want to live. here

Comments


bottom of page